KEY POINTS
- Author Paris Marx calls the current data center buildout unsustainable and says its local effects explain opposition from both political camps.
- Microsoft, Amazon and OpenAI have said they will stop using NDAs in talks with local governments, a move Marx links to community pressure.
- Marx says the industry now stresses national water figures, while he argues water use is a local problem.
Data centers have become a political flashpoint in the United States, and journalist Paris Marx argues the reason is that people can see and feel them. Marx, author of the new book Hyperscale, made the case in an interview with TechCrunch, which reported that opposition to the facilities may have helped drive the strong Democratic results in the recent midterm elections.
Marx described the current buildout as fundamentally unsustainable and out of line with a livable planet. He said a data center planned for a community is physical and material, unlike an app or an AI service. Residents, whatever their politics, may notice the effects in their power bills, their water access or the noise from rooftop cooling units. He pointed to Ron DeSantis and Bernie Sanders as examples of the bipartisan resistance.
He said several earlier cases convinced him the subject deserved a book. In Chile, communities near Santiago organized over water as Google and Microsoft built facilities. In Ireland, data centers now use more than 20% of national electricity, and in 2022 the grid operator paused new grid connections for data centers around Dublin. In The Dalles, Oregon, a reporter at The Oregonian asked how much water Google used and was met with a lawsuit. About a year later the figure emerged: 29% of the city's water.
Marx also described getting inside a hyperscale facility, which he did in New Zealand after emails to other companies went unanswered or were refused. He had to send his passport ahead of time, and every door inside required a key card. The server room was not the sinister place he had imagined. He called it utilitarian, warm and very loud because of the fans, and said visitors staying long would want earplugs.
On how the industry has responded, Marx noted that Microsoft, Amazon and OpenAI have said they will no longer use nondisclosure agreements when negotiating with local governments. He said this should make information easier to get, but he reads it as a reaction to opposition, since unanswered questions only fuel resistance. He added that companies are offering to pay for more of the electricity infrastructure and promising different water-based cooling systems.
Marx argued that the industry has shifted its messaging away from energy, where he thinks it lost the argument, and toward water. In his view, companies cite national figures, such as the water used by agriculture and golf courses, to suggest data centers are a minor concern. He said the real issue is local, because some communities hosting new facilities face real pressure on supply. The interview excerpt provided ends before he completes that point.
Marx also placed data centers within a broader pushback against the physical presence of the tech industry. He named opposition to Flock cameras, Meta's smart glasses and Waymo's self-driving cars. In his view, such targets draw anger because they can be challenged directly, whereas deleting an app does little to affect a company.