KEY POINTS
- Google's policy would require schools to keep some AI features on if students are to use Search.
- More than 500 employees signed a petition from the Alphabet Workers Union, CWA Local 9009, asking Google to reverse course.
- The New York Times reported that school districts in New York City, Los Angeles and Chicago are weighing alternative search engines.
Employees at Google are publicly opposing a company policy that ties student access to Search to the use of artificial intelligence features in schools. Engadget reported on November 19, 2026 (UTC) that members of the Alphabet Workers Union, CWA Local 9009, issued a statement criticizing the decision.
According to Engadget, Google set out the policy earlier this month as part of its handling of AI in its Classroom services for students. Under the approach, schools would essentially need to keep some AI features enabled for their students to be able to use Search.
Google's reasoning, as described in the report, is that Search and AI are deeply integrated. In the company's telling, a school that banned AI outright would therefore leave its students without Search at all.
The union statement argues that the policy works against Google's own goals. It says any chance of positive change from AI in education depends on educators being free to decide how to bring it into their curriculum. Cutting off Search for schools that do not want AI, the statement says, will not persuade users and will more likely lead them to shut out Google products altogether.
More than 500 employees signed the accompanying petition. It asks Google leadership to reconsider and to let schools turn off AI features in Search without losing the ability to use Search as a whole.
Engadget noted that the company's integration argument sits awkwardly with the fact that Google operated for decades before it launched Gemini and its other public-facing AI tools. The outlet also said the dispute is a reminder that such AI products can be turned off, and that the issue is the company's unwillingness to do so.
The worry about losing schools as customers appears to have some basis. Engadget cited The New York Times as reporting that school districts in New York City, Los Angeles and Chicago are all considering an alternative search engine. The aim, according to that report, would be to keep control over how students use AI instead of leaving that decision to Google.
The report does not say whether Google has responded to the petition or plans any change to the policy.