KEY POINTS
- Four students sued Baltimore County Public Schools, police officers and Omnilert after an AI alert mistook a chip bag for a gun in October 2025.
- An inspector general found no bias in the system but said the school's alert-handling process failed to stop a police response to a canceled alert.
- The students want an injunction blocking use of Omnilert until staff and police are trained and protocols prevent responses to false alerts.
Four current and former high school students in Maryland have filed a lawsuit over an incident in which an AI gun detection system flagged a bag of chips as a possible weapon, Ars Technica reported. The suit names the system's maker, Omnilert, as well as Baltimore County police officers, Baltimore County Public Schools (BCPS) and individual school officials.
According to the complaint, the four teens were sharing snacks after football practice in October 2025 while waiting for rides home. The detection system flagged one of them as a potential gunman. School officials who reviewed the camera footage recognized the snack bag and canceled the alert within about two minutes, which also told police that no response was needed.
The students say police came anyway. They allege that at least six patrol cars arrived with lights on and that some officers had their guns drawn. The complaint says the teens were separated, made to kneel on concrete, handcuffed and searched without being told why. They also say they suffered marks on their wrists and lasting emotional distress.
A later review by the Office of the Inspector General for Education found no bias in Omnilert's system. It did, however, fault the authority delegation process at Kenwood High School. Per the report, the principal saw the alert but missed that it had been canceled, and about 15 minutes later texted a school resource officer to send police, while noting in the message that the object was "maybe not" a gun. The report indicates she had not been trained on the system.
The inspector general recommended twice-yearly training, a review of BCPS safety protocols and fewer people receiving gun alerts. It also suggested using the Omnilert app, because the principal viewed the alert in a text message and could have overlooked the cancellation notice.
The students argue those steps fall short. They cite the inspector general's finding that more than 99 percent of alerts in the district were false positives requiring no police response, and say the principal should have verified the threat. The suit alleges unlawful search and detention and claims the district showed deliberate indifference to students' constitutional rights. It asks a court to bar BCPS from using Omnilert until staff and police are adequately trained and procedures prevent police responses to canceled alerts.
The Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights Under Law, which represents the teens, says the case shows the risk of over-relying on AI. Its president, Damon Hewitt, called the mix of that reliance and poor coordination among officials "toxic." The complaint also says Omnilert advertises "near-zero false positives" without ensuring the human review that claim depends on.
BCPS declined to comment and pointed to an earlier statement to parents promising counseling and emotional support. Omnilert vice president Blake Mitchell said the company is reviewing the complaint and is sorry for what the students went through. He argued the case shows why human review matters and why "a canceled alert must stay canceled."